State alimony comparison
Recommended workflow
Start with the legal differences below, run one shared estimate scenario, then open each state guide for the detailed framework courts may apply.
Use this side-by-side data view as a starting point, then review the linked state law guides and calculators for deeper planning context.
| Factor | New York | South Dakota |
|---|---|---|
| Support term | maintenance | alimony |
| Formula profile | statutory | discretionary |
| Property system | equitable | equitable |
| Legal framework | Temporary maintenance during divorce proceedings is calculated using statutory formulas established in Domestic Relations Law § 236(B)(5-a). Post-divorce maintenance is governed by § 236(B)(6), where courts apply statutory formulas, duration advisory ranges, and deviation factors before entering a final award. | Temporary alimony may be awarded while the divorce action is pending under S.D. Codified Laws § 25-4-38. Final alimony is governed by § 25-4-41 and is determined through judicial discretion rather than a fixed calculation. |
| Statute citation | New York Domestic Relations Law § 236(B)(5-a) (temporary maintenance) and § 236(B)(6) (post-divorce maintenance) | S.D. Codified Laws §§ 25-4-38, 25-4-40, 25-4-41, and 25-4-42 |
Best for
Relocation planning, negotiation prep, and state-by-state estimate checks.
Use with
New York and South Dakota calculators for same-fact estimates.
Remember
Support outcomes still depend on judge discretion, facts, and local procedure.
Same-facts estimate
Use the same income and marriage facts to see how the planning estimate changes between New York and South Dakota. This is educational, not a court prediction.
Guideline maintenance estimate using New York's higher formula: 30% of payer income minus 20% of recipient income, capped so the recipient does not receive more than 40% of combined income after maintenance. If the maintenance payer is also the noncustodial parent paying child support, New York uses a lower formula: 20% of payer income minus 25% of recipient income.
$2,000/mo
Planning range: $1,600-$2,400/mo
Duration: About 3 years
Conservative educational estimate based on need, ability to pay, income disparity, marriage length, earning capacity, post-divorce financial condition, age, health, marital standard of living, property division, and South Dakota equitable factors; no mandatory statewide formula applies.
$1,400/mo
Planning range: $910-$1,890/mo
Duration: Medium to long marriage
South Dakota relies heavily on court discretion or limited eligibility rules, so this estimate should be treated as a broad planning range.
New York: New York uses statutory guideline formulas for temporary and post-divorce maintenance on the payor's income up to the statutory income cap. The formulas are presumptive guideline calculations, but courts may adjust or deviate if the guideline amount is unjust or inappropriate after considering statutory factors. Maintenance above the income cap is discretionary. South Dakota: Conservative educational estimate based on need, ability to pay, income disparity, marriage length, earning capacity, post-divorce financial condition, age, health, marital standard of living, property division, and South Dakota equitable factors; no mandatory statewide formula applies.
New York: New York uses a nonmandatory advisory duration schedule for post-divorce maintenance. For marriages up to and including 15 years, guideline duration is generally 15% to 30% of the marriage length. For marriages over 15 years and up to 20 years, guideline duration is generally 30% to 40% of the marriage length. For marriages over 20 years, guideline duration is generally 35% to 50% of the marriage length. Temporary maintenance lasts only while the divorce case is pending. South Dakota: South Dakota has no fixed statutory duration formula. Temporary alimony may be awarded while the divorce is pending. Post-divorce alimony may be rehabilitative, restitutional, permanent, or another equitable form depending on the facts. Rehabilitative support may be time-limited and tied to education, training, or self-support. Permanent or longer-term support may be possible where age, disability, health, or long-term dependency prevents self-support, but it is not automatic.
New York: Maintenance orders may be modified when statutory standards for modification are satisfied, including qualifying changes in circumstances. Separation agreements and judgments may contain additional provisions affecting modification rights. South Dakota: South Dakota alimony may be modified when a substantial change in circumstances justifies review, depending on the award type and decree terms. Courts evaluate changes affecting need, income, earning capacity, health, or ability to pay.
New York uses the term maintenance for spousal support and employs statutory formulas that provide presumptive maintenance amounts in many cases. Courts begin with the statutory calculation but may deviate when the formula would be unjust or inappropriate after considering statutory factors. Maintenance awards are intended to address economic disparities created by the marriage and divorce.
Eligibility: A spouse may qualify for maintenance when there is a demonstrated economic disparity and the statutory analysis supports an award. Courts review the parties' incomes, property distribution, future earning potential, and financial circumstances. Qualification does not require fault and is evaluated under the statutory framework.
South Dakota authorizes alimony when a divorce is granted and permits the court to require one spouse to make a suitable allowance for the other's support. The state does not use a mandatory statewide formula. Courts rely on discretionary factors such as marriage length, earning capacity, financial condition, age, health, social standing, and fault-related responsibility for the breakup.
Eligibility: A spouse may qualify if the court finds support suitable after reviewing the parties' financial and personal circumstances. South Dakota courts consider marriage length, earning ability, property division, age, health, social standing, and fault or responsibility for the divorce. Eligibility depends on equity rather than a strict income threshold.
Alimony rules vary by state. Comparing two states helps readers understand differences in formulas, duration ranges, eligibility rules, modification standards, and judicial discretion before deeper research.
No. SettleCompass comparison pages are educational planning resources only and do not replace advice from a licensed family law attorney.
Yes. State formulas, income caps, duration rules, statutory factors, and judge discretion can produce different outcomes from the same basic facts.
Use state-specific calculator pages to model the same income and marriage-length assumptions across both states.
